Pizza Athena in Palmer

Pizza Athena in Palmer
4 / 5
50 reviews

3539 Glenn Highway, Palmer, AK 99645, Palmer

Overview

Cuisine
  • Pizza
  • Italian
Features
  • Delivery
  • Takeout

Restaurant Hours

Monday

10:30 am

Wednesday

10:30 am

Friday

10:30 am

Sunday

10:30 am

Why is there so little linguisa on the pizza... disappointed~!!

I no the staff would more then help make this next pizza just the way you would like. But you have to call the phone girl/cook/guy or just say the one to take order. On the day of and they will try and make right. FYI have cost of ticket and about time of order just to help look your order up. They have for me.

Review

Add rating restaurant:
Pizza Athena
LM
Lisa Mecham
google
11.21.2024
5/5

Best pizza and calazon I have had since we moved here 5 yrs ago . Great quality amazing flavors fresh ingredients I could go on forever. I'll be back to try more off the menu !

Pizza Athena
LC
Lamont Cain
google
09.14.2018
5/5

My wife and I do not generally try new 🍕 places. Decided to be different for a change. Sandwiches and pizza were both appreciated and very well liked. Thanks Pizza Athena for one of the best meals we've had in a long time. Keep it up.

Pizza Athena
MJ
Misty Johnson
google
09.01.2018
5/5

AMAZING COOK(S)!!! The pizza is always delivered HOT (I even had to blow in mine and set it by the fan) and do NOT get me started on their breadsticks!! I HIGHLY recommend this place!!! Sammy is literally the BEST pizza cook!! But then again, they all are. You will not be dissapointed I promise!!! Also, try their chicken sandwich! To die for!!!

Pizza Athena
BL
B Lopes
google
06.27.2018
5/5

Yummmmmmmmmmmmmm! Best food in town. We have ordered many of the great foods on Pizza Athena's menu. They have all been great. OH MY GOODNESS the Philly Cheese Steak sandwich is the best we have ever eaten and it is huge. The pizza (all of them) are the best. Pizza Athena is Palmer's little slice of heaven. Small place delivery or pickup only and there is usually a wait due to the volume of business. It is worth the wait so plan ahead or pickup. I have waited as long as two hours for my delivery but the food was hot and good.

Pizza Athena
EH
Estaban Hill
google
06.24.2018
5/5

Great pizza with friendly service Thanks for the good food !

Pizza Athena
CM
Chelsey M.
google
06.20.2018
5/5

Yummy pizza

Pizza Athena
NT
Nathaniel Terpening
google
06.14.2018
5/5

Yum! Enough said.Ok but in all seriousness, it's great. The specialty pizzas are amazing. There's something for everyone. Run to the shop and pick it up or have it delivered. The staff are great and always have a smile. It's worth it.

Pizza Athena
KA
Keith Austin
google
06.01.2018
5/5

Great Pizza, Convenient Location and Fast Service.

Pizza Athena
MM
Michael Martin
google
03.01.2018
1/5

Every time we have ordered from them, they mess up the order. This last time we called them about their mess up, all the people we talked to about it sounded high. Absolutely terrible pizza company, do not recommend. If I could give less than 1 star, I would

Pizza Athena
SG
Stolgrove Gredenko
google
02.27.2018
5/5

Greek style pizzas, very excellent. Be aware of the use of feta when you may not expect it.

Pizza Athena
DH
Donna Howe
google
02.19.2018
5/5

Great pizza and great service.

Pizza Athena
CH
Charles Howard
google
01.17.2018
5/5

Definitely a local favorite

Pizza Athena
MM
M M
google
01.02.2018
5/5

Crazy good pizza. I've eaten a lot of pizza in AK, this is in the top 2. Don't let the disaster of a property turn you away. These guys make an extraordinarily high quality and authentic New York pizza. All of the pizza in the Valley except Athena and one other is terrible.

Pizza Athena
HP
Hillary Palmer
google
10.27.2017
5/5

Best pizza and Greek food in town! We usually get the feta bread and feta lovers salad. Their sandwiches, Greek fries and pasta salad are awesome too.

Pizza Athena
PS
Pete Sandor
google
10.15.2017
5/5

The food is great, and so are the employees... Coming from an Italian from Ny who moved to the area it's hard to find a great pizza place and Athena rates up there...

Pizza Athena
ZW
Zandra Woods
google
07.24.2017
5/5

A year ago I left a 1 star review. We decided to try again and it was amazing! From what I’ve read it’s under new ownership and they turned that place around! So delicious!

Pizza Athena
CR
Cody Riezinstein
google
07.22.2017
5/5

Decent prices, Great pizza and wings! Super friendly people!

Pizza Athena
FB
Frankie Blooding
google
06.27.2017
3/5

Expensive and not the best pizza. It was good, but for that price, I expected more, I guess.

Pizza Athena
JI
Julia Inga
google
06.11.2017
5/5

Awesome pizzas and food

Pizza Athena
jH
james Hays
google
06.11.2017
5/5

The quality is there as well as service!

Pizza Athena
CB
Cemile Blue
google
05.09.2017
5/5

Good place to make a qick stop and a bite on the go.

Pizza Athena
Michael
google
05.02.2017
5/5

Best pizza. They deliver really far. Open late

Pizza Athena
TL
Tonchee Lonewolf
google
04.26.2017
2/5

There pizza was nasty felt like they messed it up on purpose plus tipped reallyGood 16.00 dollars for crape

Pizza Athena
JA
Jo Anna Hansen
google
04.17.2017
2/5

Ready in 40/45 min... 75 minutes later.... 3 check in on the order at 40 min, 60 min and 75 min. Each time... what did you order again? It’s 10:32 pm and the cook has my pizza in the warmer, I didn’t know they were here I have to cut it still. Now I remember why I only order from them when I’m desperate. I order from here maybe twice a year. Happens every time.

Pizza Athena
SA
Stan Awe
google
04.16.2017
5/5

Excellent service and awesome food. No matter what you order it is past excellent. Soooooo much better than Pioneer Pizza in so many ways!!! It is pleasant every time satisfaction every time.

Pizza Athena
KD
Kenny Duby
google
04.10.2017
4/5

Always Great..Athena meat sub wrap..one of my favorites.

Pizza Athena
RR
Reverend Richard Stoneking
google
03.23.2017
3/5

Seemed alright. Started a reservation when we showed up instead of agreed upon time. They were quick about it at least.

Pizza Athena
JL
Jessica Lawler
google
03.22.2017
5/5

Everything was amazing as always. They are my top go to for anything pizza, pasta, or cheese bread.

Pizza Athena
jh
james hays
google
03.06.2017
5/5

Awesome food!

Pizza Athena
AE
Amus Evans
google
03.04.2017
5/5

Best pizza in the Am 👍the pizza man by far blows all pizza company's out of the business... Hands down

Pizza Athena
TG
Thor Gallagher
google
02.07.2017
1/5

I liked them but they only allow one 8oz ranch per order (even if you have a big family.) I ordered from them and they did not deliver when the said they would, so I called them back to see what was taking so long (they wrote down the we were picking up the pizzas when we asked them for delivery) they said that they world deliver the pizzas (cold) but I asked them to make new ones and deliver them hot but the hung up on us 3 times! Terrible customer service so I will not be ordering from them ever again!

Pizza Athena
yh
yohanan harvey
google
01.09.2017
1/5

If you're door dash don't go. They will take 40+ min to get order ready. Waste of time.

Pizza Athena
AS
Athena Schreur
google
11.22.2016
4/5

The Athena Special pizza was great! I would definitely eat here again, very good and unique options on the menu.

Pizza Athena
DL
Dayle Little
google
11.15.2016
2/5

Ordered 3 topping pizza, got 2 toppings and ordered a Greek salad that had no FETA

Pizza Athena
ZR
Zandra Ruff
google
11.13.2016
1/5

I just moved to Palmer and had already tried another local pizza place. I was disappointed by them. So we decided to try Athena and it was hands down the worst pizza from a restaurant I’ve ever had. A boxed pizza from the store is better than theirs. Greasy, bland, crust was burnt and the toppings were soggy. So disappointing.

Pizza Athena
jh
jason harbuck
google
11.01.2016
4/5

Great food

Pizza Athena
CS
Cory Sands
google
09.10.2016
5/5

It is under new and more effective ownership. And this one blows the old pizza shop out the water. And have the best pizza and prices in town.

Pizza Athena
JD
James Davis
google
08.26.2016
5/5

Good place to eat

Pizza Athena
RT
Robert Tarkington
google
08.17.2016
4/5

Those folks are great And the food is good to 4 stars

Pizza Athena
WE
Wolverine Equestrian Park
google
08.14.2016
5/5

I love pizza athena! The crust is amazing and the pizza is always hot, even if I am late picking up, the pizza is always ready, fresh, and the staff are friendly and fun.

Pizza Athena
RG
Robert Gardner
google
08.05.2016
5/5

Good is the best I've had in mat su valley

Pizza Athena
MD
Mike Davidson
google
07.25.2016
5/5

Amazing pizza, fast service, great stop for pizza!

Pizza Athena
TC
Tina Cruz
google
07.22.2016
5/5

We needed a fast meal tonight, so we stopped into Pizza Athena for the first time. The folks were beyond inviting and friendly. We got home with our nice hot yummy pizza and really enjoyed every bite! Thank you,Rich & Tina Fogel

Pizza Athena
QF
Quinn Falkner
google
05.24.2016
5/5

The Pizza Athena pizza I had today (and typically) rates literally #1 of any pizza I have ever had in 50 years- ranging from Colorado to Alaska! (& I don't usually leave reviews). Amazing!!

Pizza Athena
KS
Kyle Schmitt
google
03.23.2016
5/5

Had a very interesting experience tonight with DoorDash and Pizza Athena, lots of confusion but Pizza Athena credited my account due to all the issues because of Doordash.

Pizza Athena
CB
Christina Borge
google
03.10.2016
5/5

Great pizza, excellent service

Pizza Athena
MS
Michael Smith
google
03.09.2016
4/5

The pizza and the other food they have is great. Their customer service could definitely use some work. And they need a better waiting area for pick ups.

Pizza Athena
AS
Anyes Stanton
google
03.06.2016
5/5

Delicious . This pizzería is out of the box.The regular crust is soft, but it keeps the consistecy of a pie, Fair ammount of toppings. Always pick up or delivery on time and hot. Lucky 2 have them in my área.👌

Pizza Athena
W2
Wolfie 2442
google
02.16.2016
3/5

Not too bad I guess

Pizza Athena
AS
AmyJo Smith
google
02.12.2016
5/5

This is probably the hottest I've ever had delivered - like, if I'd gone and picked it up myself it wouldn't have made it to my house as hot as it is. And it's delicious!

Your question has been sent.

Expect an answer!

Thank!

Your review has been submitted.

Order food

Reservation

Want to order over the phone?

Call 19077456646

Thank you for being with us!

We will call you back!